Bravo! I’ve been discussing this with some classmates recently. I expressed my much greater fondness for stylized games, mostly for stylization sake. Didn’t we all get thrilled by video games because of the strange places they can take us? If I wanted to play Call Of Duty, I’d join the military and get paid lots of money (Poor example, as CoD doesn’t involve actual dying ).
I feel bad for have not knowing what the uncanny valley was XD thanks for the history lesson. I definitely prefer my characters stylized! I play video games to be immersed in a new world, not thrown into a stimulated version of this one -_-
I’m not sure I would call Final Fantasy stylized. I mean, it’s definitely not realistic, but it strives for a “human” look. It’s just waxy, fashion blind magical humans, but still humans as we know them.
Theory(if you can call it that xD): Maybe if some studio anonced a movie that was CGI AND did not tell it, then maybe…. or maybe not.. it should of cause be kind of “photorealistic” something like Pixar movies are obviously not Photo-real but maybe if it was close to the other side of the uncanny valley, we wouldent notice? if i make my mind up, i even dont think that myself but someone had to say this, not?
halo/final fantasy series probably weren’t the best examples. Taking a look at that live action halo game teaser doesn’t quite strike the stylization plan.. Square-enix tries so damn hard these days to make their games look like a fashion show.
My examples would be the characters from Little big planet and Machinarium.
The uncanny valley got to movies even more. Dropping any names would result in a flame, but cgi-driven movies are a lot less realistic than the old ones, fact. Human eye knows.
I have to admit, that was part of WoW’s appeal for me, too. I tend to prefer games on the stylized end of things, in part because of the uncanny valley and not just with regards to humans. Animals and environments that don’t act to my expectations also become turn-offs. Makes me somewhat uneasy that there’s this obsessive push towards realism, to the exclusion of more stylized representations, which I fear will eventually become a rarity — relegated to servicing “kiddy” markets, as cartoons are
this video was excellent! i knew what uncanny valley was before, but you just cleared it up so much more for me.
i have this problem when it comes to robots, but i love final fantasy LOL
Actually, games in this current generation do need good graphics to be successful, and that is a good thing. If they have the technology at their disposal, then the graphics should be a no brainer after gameplay. Daniel makes an excellent point and a way to prove that in this video.
The Other side of the valley is Robots taking over and Sky-net waging war and Covenant Carriers Glassing New Mombassa Reapers cleansing earth of all life and uhhh China…. Having a Military….scary
Im the opposite side of the spectrum
WoW just dont appeal to me because none of it feels real
it just looks like a big, basic and bad simulation.
Allthough generall MMOs dont appeal to me either
clikc a dude, watch you and him take swings at eachother…
I dont require photorealism, but regardlessly i want to feel like im there, you know?
that it’s got basic laws of physics right, and it feels like it could be real.
this is so true. the uncanny valley is probably the reason world of warcraft was so appealing to me, compared to other MMOs out there. all the characters seem cartoony and stylized. mmo’s like guild wars, lotro, and most of korea’s mmo’s all try to push for realism..which just doesnt appeal to me. the uncanny valley is also pretty apparent in bethesda’s games like Oblivion or Fallout 3..but great games otherwise
March 5th, 2010 at 2:20 pm
Bravo! I’ve been discussing this with some classmates recently. I expressed my much greater fondness for stylized games, mostly for stylization sake. Didn’t we all get thrilled by video games because of the strange places they can take us? If I wanted to play Call Of Duty, I’d join the military and get paid lots of money (Poor example, as CoD doesn’t involve actual dying
).
March 5th, 2010 at 2:22 pm
Why did the first song sound familiar.
This is so well-put together and cute haha.
I don’t think I have a very strong uncanny valley as of thus far.
March 5th, 2010 at 2:57 pm
lol keanu reaves XD
March 5th, 2010 at 3:54 pm
That…. THING at 2:01(and other spots) gives me the creeps.
Laughed at 2:04.
Overall, nice. Entertaining. :3
March 5th, 2010 at 4:21 pm
I feel bad for have not knowing what the uncanny valley was XD thanks for the history lesson. I definitely prefer my characters stylized! I play video games to be immersed in a new world, not thrown into a stimulated version of this one -_-
March 5th, 2010 at 4:43 pm
your voice annoys me
March 5th, 2010 at 5:31 pm
I’m not sure I would call Final Fantasy stylized. I mean, it’s definitely not realistic, but it strives for a “human” look. It’s just waxy, fashion blind magical humans, but still humans as we know them.
March 5th, 2010 at 5:43 pm
hey wow, this is one of the most well put together videos i’ve seen, excellent work
March 5th, 2010 at 5:59 pm
Theory(if you can call it that xD): Maybe if some studio anonced a movie that was CGI AND did not tell it, then maybe…. or maybe not.. it should of cause be kind of “photorealistic” something like Pixar movies are obviously not Photo-real but maybe if it was close to the other side of the uncanny valley, we wouldent notice? if i make my mind up, i even dont think that myself but someone had to say this, not?
March 5th, 2010 at 6:21 pm
I like realism in my games. going the other way is going backwards.
March 5th, 2010 at 6:28 pm
halo/final fantasy series probably weren’t the best examples. Taking a look at that live action halo game teaser doesn’t quite strike the stylization plan.. Square-enix tries so damn hard these days to make their games look like a fashion show.
My examples would be the characters from Little big planet and Machinarium.
The uncanny valley got to movies even more. Dropping any names would result in a flame, but cgi-driven movies are a lot less realistic than the old ones, fact. Human eye knows.
March 5th, 2010 at 7:23 pm
I have to admit, that was part of WoW’s appeal for me, too. I tend to prefer games on the stylized end of things, in part because of the uncanny valley and not just with regards to humans. Animals and environments that don’t act to my expectations also become turn-offs. Makes me somewhat uneasy that there’s this obsessive push towards realism, to the exclusion of more stylized representations, which I fear will eventually become a rarity — relegated to servicing “kiddy” markets, as cartoons are
March 5th, 2010 at 8:05 pm
Cool, never heard about that term before. It sure makes sense
March 5th, 2010 at 8:10 pm
this video was excellent! i knew what uncanny valley was before, but you just cleared it up so much more for me.
i have this problem when it comes to robots, but i love final fantasy LOL
March 5th, 2010 at 8:17 pm
Awesome explanation of the uncanny valley
March 5th, 2010 at 8:27 pm
Actually, games in this current generation do need good graphics to be successful, and that is a good thing. If they have the technology at their disposal, then the graphics should be a no brainer after gameplay. Daniel makes an excellent point and a way to prove that in this video.
March 5th, 2010 at 9:12 pm
The Other side of the valley is Robots taking over and Sky-net waging war and Covenant Carriers Glassing New Mombassa Reapers cleansing earth of all life and uhhh China…. Having a Military….scary
March 5th, 2010 at 9:57 pm
Im the opposite side of the spectrum
WoW just dont appeal to me because none of it feels real
it just looks like a big, basic and bad simulation.
Allthough generall MMOs dont appeal to me either
clikc a dude, watch you and him take swings at eachother…
I dont require photorealism, but regardlessly i want to feel like im there, you know?
that it’s got basic laws of physics right, and it feels like it could be real.
March 5th, 2010 at 10:45 pm
I mean not just final fantasy X… but ALL of final fantasy series!!!
March 5th, 2010 at 11:14 pm
this guy has it wrong w/ respect to final fantasy X… I find that FFX hits itself directly at the BOTTOM of the uncanny valley!!!
March 6th, 2010 at 12:12 am
your video lectures are a big help for animation topics and essays. your awsome, i put your video in my class presentation and essay. awsomness
March 6th, 2010 at 12:21 am
Dude I don’t even know if what your saying is true. U do know that it was fun to watch and hopefully educational. 5 stars
March 6th, 2010 at 12:51 am
this is so true. the uncanny valley is probably the reason world of warcraft was so appealing to me, compared to other MMOs out there. all the characters seem cartoony and stylized. mmo’s like guild wars, lotro, and most of korea’s mmo’s all try to push for realism..which just doesnt appeal to me. the uncanny valley is also pretty apparent in bethesda’s games like Oblivion or Fallout 3..but great games otherwise
March 6th, 2010 at 1:18 am
Superb video. Thank you. Been looking for a nice, simple definition fo the valley for a long time.
5/5
March 6th, 2010 at 1:42 am
I busted out laughing when keanu reeves showed up.